Corey: I so often forget that she is Austrailian.

I predict: Atonement

Winner:  Sweeney Todd

I'm sorry but it has been done before. But I guess the same could be said for Atonement as they are both set in the PAST.

Andy: Best Art Direction is a tricky thing.  The wilder it is, the "better" it is.  I'd have to go with SWEENEY TODD.

And it won!